Review: City Theatre wraps up ‘Christmas at Pemberley’ trilogy with a satisfying bow

Be sure to read out Seven with Sue (+1) Q&A with director Bria Walker-Rhoze

City Theatre wrapped up a trilogy to kick off the holiday season with a flourish. I cannot emphasize how much I want you to see this show.

The Christmas at Pemberly series by Lauren Gunderson and Margot Melcon offers a lovely post-Pride and Prejudice examaination of a significant question – what to the other girls? Jane Austen gifted us with the happily-ever-after tales of older sisters Jane and Elizabeth. The stories of the other young women remained tantalizingly unfinished. Director Bria Walker-Rhoze describes our fascination with the muddy hemmed heroine drawing us back, time and again to Jane Austen.

The other young women are three sisters – Mary, Lydia, and Kitty along with Georgiana Dary and wee appearance by Anne de Bourgh. While Austen did not expand upon their narratives, the playwrights found enough fodder for three separaty plays, all tied to celebrating the Christmas holidays at Pemberley.

Mary Bennet’s blossoming holds up well to the very popular ‘The Other Bennett Sister’ that captivated the Britbox crowd over the past year. While the stories differ, the spirit is the same and we can be forgiven to want two endings to be true at the same time.

The second play is all about Lydia and the backstory of the vile Mr. Wickham.

Finally, we have Kitty Bennett and her best friend, Georgiana Darcy. The play plays a little fast and loose with the fact that Kitty is the fourth sister, not the youngest. But the two unmarried sisters-in-law forming a strong attachment is believable. Their fates remain intertwined even as their paths seemingly diverge.

Kitty is the boisterous younger sister, once again drawn into the orbit of another young woman – first Lydia and then Georgiana. While a bit of a wallflower with Lydia, Georgiana brings out Kitty’s unique gifts, her pragmatism and loyalty.

Georgiana is a gifted pianist with a huge fortune. Her attempt to bring the man she loves into the family fold is disastrous thanks to his timidity and the unerring pompousity of Mr. Fitzwilliam Darcy. The man is Henry Clay who along with his good friend Thomas O’Brien stops in to visit the family over the holidays.

Just when the audience expects a happily ever after, Lydia – oh, yes, Lydia fresh and humbled by the end of her marriage to Wickham, that Lydia takes action to help Georgiana and sets in motion the misunderstandings and miscommunication that drives every Regency novel. It is the silence, the things people don’t say as much as the mistaken things they do blurt out that underlies this dynamic.

We fast forward six years. Georgiana has come into her fortune and established a home in London. Her frustration at the intrusion of men, including bother her brother and Wickham and yes, Mr. Gay, into her life feed her determination to be silent no more. She goes to great acclaim as a pianist and launches a music society for women.

Meanwhile, Kitty has met a man who adores her and supports her endeavor to launch the music society. Kitty is not musical, but is an efficient executive.

There are some happy endings, a sly twist that we could see coming a million miles away but did add a little something special to the story.

This was a satisfying end to the trilogy although I hold out hope for more tales from one of my favorite universes.

Notice that Kitty is watching Georgina while everyone else is looking at Lizzie. photo credit KJH Studios

The cast did a terrific job. Kitty (Annalisa D’Aguilar) and Georgiana (Olivia Leigh Ruenkha) had lovely chemistry, united with and admidst the chaos of the Bennet sisters. Returning to their roles are Alex Manalo as Jane Bingham, Juan Rivera LeBron as Mr. Darcy, and Gabrille Kogut as Mary Bennet/de Bourgh. But the trifecta is with Alex Sheffield who shines as Lydia Wickham in all three productions. Rounding out the Bennet sisters is Evelyn Hernandez as Lizzie. Nick Grosso as Henry Grey and Isaac Miller as Thomas O’Brien. Bria Walker-Rhoze spoke briefly about the use of color-blind casting for this production, something we’ve seen more frequently in Pittsburgh with the glaring exception of some mid-century classics. That’s a loss for all of us.

Kitty and Lydia photo credit KJH Studios

Alex Sheffield has been terrific in all three plans of the trilogy. Her evolution from self-absorbed, self-deluded dilettant with a genuine heart to a delightfully charming mature woman in her 20’s is palpable. As the only actor to appear in all three plays, there’s literally no comparison. I did think Kogut’s second turn as Mary Bennet/de Bourgh was also a lovely display of growth almost tender as she discussed a women’s music society.

D’Aguilar and O’Brien clicked instantly like two puzzle pieces. For the besties to be involved with male chums was fitting. O’Brien brought some balance as a lively gentleman who supports his love’s endeavors, not just tolerate them. He is amiable like Bingley, but seemingly less prone to external influence.

The set was lovely and conveyed a multi-year arc with small touches, including moving from a partial Christmas tree to a full fledged six foot plus beauty. It was a bit like turning a snow globe upside down. Tony Ferrieri did a great job, especially returning to the magical snowflake curtain. Hugh Hanson’s costuming was excellent. We were seated very close to the stage so I had a chance to look closely at the costumes. The gloves really my eye as did the layering of dresses that might faciliate a quick change. Putting Lydia in muff with coordinated hat was that small detail that shines.

What really caught me was the transformation of Kitty and Georgiana from girls to young adult women. At the beginning of this play, Kitty would have been 22 and Georgiana 20. The incongruity with Lydia’s age is a cause for some concern, but we can safely say our young leads are 28 and 26 by the end of the play. Lydia might be 26 or 28. Does it matter? We wouldn’t be watching and reviewing this play if details did not matter.

The costuming was key to that making this transformation believable. This is the first time jump in the trilogy. While the other sisters were already married or soon-to-be-married, these two filled out their lives from girlhood to adulthood. They both looked signinficantly older as you’d expect for a six year time lapse. While not as impressive as the character aging process of Amy March, it was impressive.

The only flaw was the primary relationship – Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy. While he does redeem himself with the help of womenfolk, it doesn’t seem to last from play to play. Elizabeth is a bit more of a manipulative influence than a counterbalance her husband.

The story ends on a satisfying. I might go again to observe in more detail the set, the costuming, and the hairstyles.

This should be another record breaking holiday production for City Theatre and a must see for everyone who loves period pieces, romances, the Regency era, and Jane Austen.

Georgiana & Kitty runs through Sun, Dec 6, 2026 at City Theatre on the Southside.

I plan to dive back into Pride and Prejudice quite soon, looking forward to the next opportunity to look back at the legacy of one of the world’s greatest novels and novelists.

How lovely it would be to see the trilogy staged together.

Holiday Spirits Captivate Pemberley for this City Theatre Production – 2023

‘The Wickhams’ Takes Us Below the Stairs at Pemberley – 2024

Liked it? Take a second to support Sue on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

Discover more from Pittsburgh Lesbian Correspondents

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.