Why the disdain on civil disobedience KDKA and Commander Rashelle Brackney?

Yesterday, members of Northside United engaged in acts of civil disobedience to bring attention to their struggle for community benefits from the mega-development on the “Northshore.”  Protestors blocked a building entrance.  The media showed up and I was appalled at their condescending treatment of this exercise in their civil rights.

Here's the video from KDKA http://kdka.com/video/?id=60191@kdka.dayport.com

John Shumway of KDKA was just unbelievably patronizing.  Feminist dyke rant move on.   It takes a lot of freaking gaul for a white man whose path to a career in broadcast journalism was a foregone conclusion from the moment of his freaking conception to stand in MY neighborhood and speak down about a group of community activists engaging in a time proven civil rights tactic to bring attention to the plight of low-income urban residents who didn't have that privileges of birth that Mr. Shumway enjoys. 

This is the same station that tracks down the limo driver from Michael Jackson's last tour stop in Pittsburgh (1988?  1998?) for the local angle on MJ's death.  This is the same man who will shove his microphone into the faces of grieving family members and shell shocked neighbors to meet his yinzer exploitation quota for the evening, but he can't use his professional skills to cover a story about poverty, community activisim and corporate greed?  Are you freaking kidding me, Shumway?  You might want to thumb through the wikipedia entry on civil disobedience to get a little refresher on the long history of non violent actions to respond to injustice perpetrated by the man.  But you are in fact someone who benefits from the man's systems so why would you need to do your homework? 

I was also disappointed with the barely disguised scorn and laughter of Zone 1 Commander Rashelle Brackney.  Command Brackney must have forgotten that repeated acts of civil disobedience by African-Americans and women throughout the 20th Century paved the way for her ascent to power in the City police force.  I get that she is unable to condone breaking the law, but she could have acted like a leader in the Northside instead of a condescending public official.  Let us not forget that she was dragged away from the very important work of ticketing cars in the Mexican War Streets that are parked the wrong direction. I used to be a fan of Commander Brackney, but the day she failed to call someone out for describing as “nuts and fruits” the children in our neighborhoods she lost my support.  I guess she's willing to go to bat for certain children, but not those with mental illness and those who are gay. 

It is dismaying that as corruption in our City government continues to come to light, public safety officials and the fourth estate turn a blind eye to residents trying to accomplish something good for their community.  They aren't running around Pittsburgh dressed up like costume characters.  They aren't raving about conspiracies.  They are trying to build a better lives for their families. 

A critical analysis of the effectiveness of the campaign would be fine, even deeming it ineffective.  Commander Brackney could have said nothing.  KDKA producers could have smacked Shumway in the head (figuratively) and sent him back to the editing room to put together a decent story. 

Instead, we have another example of systemic support for corporate America at the cost of hard-working Americans who just want a shot at improving their lives. 


For 18+ years,  snowflakes, social justice warriors, and the politically correct have built this blog. Follow us on Twitter @Pghlesbian24

We need your ongoing support to maintain this archive and continue the work. Please consider becoming a patron of this blog with a recurring monthly donation or make a one-time donation.

Venmo @PghLesbian  CashApp $PghLesbian



This post and/or others may contain affiliate links. Your purchase through these links support our work. You are under no obligation to make a purchase.

  • No reason for a reporter to keep it a secret that the protesters alerted the police and the media beforehand … but by focusing the whole story through that minor novelty, I have a feeling KDKA won't be on the list the next time Northside United has some interesting news to offer.
    Now this…
    “a white man whose path to a career in broadcast journalism was a foregone conclusion from the moment of his freaking conception…”
    Sorry, this rhetoric just f'ing grates already. I'm a white man who's made a few attempts to crack into the journalism field, and throughout my life into a few other things, and I can assure you nobody has ever to bowed and give me the red carpet treatment once I showed them my white male card. I think your view on how easy life must be for everyone who doesn't share your own crosses to bear is skewed, and I think your advocacy would be more effective if you digested that.

  • I'm not going to have this conversation with someone who thinks white male privilege is a red carpet. Clearly, we have no common ground for a fruitful discussion.
    I wrote, you responded, let's move on.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.