First of all, I did not denigrate Doug Shields, but actually lauded his long history of civil rights activism. I merely expressed disappointment that he didn't mention any new policy initiatives. I don't agree with Doug on all things, but I don't doubt his sincere commitment to LGBT equality. However, his alliance with Luke Ravenstahl troubles me b/c Luke's surrogate didn't propose anything new either. Plus, Doug did a lot of damage to his rep (in my eyes only perhaps) with his snarky comments about smoking in city hall. That was very disrespectful and as someone with asthma, I find it offensive that he would take my well being so lightly.
As for Michael Lamb, I gushed because he's new to me and I'm impressed. He did make commitments on moving LGBT issues ahead. Doug did not. That was the difference.
Finally, the fatted calf. How long do you rest on your laurels? Many of the so called leaders in the LGBT community traded their votes (and their shekels) for the right to hold a drunken street festival after PrideFest and the alleged promise of Luke to come to PrideFest itself. A promise Luke's surrogate knew nothing about.
Call me crazy, but I'm concerned that any further city/county service mergers guarantee domestic partner benefits for city employees. Because that matters to me. Drinking beer in the middle of Liberty Avenue while Tiffany sings isn't so critical to my future.
When Doug Shields publically admits he was wrong to smoke in the city-county building and pledges not to do it anymore, I'll reconsider my vote.