I don't understand why it 's supposed to be somehow better to be against gay marriage because of your religion vs. because you dislike gays vs. because you think it will somehow 'harm' straight marriages vs. any other reason.
The end result is the same so why should someone who favors gay marriage vote for you?
Is it that because your religion forbids it the responsibility is somehow lessened for you? No one is forcing you to follow that religion. It's your choice to follow it and your choice to decide to agree with all or any of its dogma.
I just don't get it.